Solana launches AS identity authentication service. How is it different from an oracle?

The oracle is a "data feeding" mechanism that focuses on "objective facts" outside the chain; while the Attestation Service is a "authentication identity or status" mechanism that focuses on "subjective or conditional trust" outside the chain.

Solana launches AS identity authentication service. How is it different from an oracle?

Editor/ far@Centreless

X (Twitter) @Tocentreles

On May 24, Solana published a blog on its official website stating that the Solana Identity Group and the Solana Foundation announced that the Solana Authentication Service (SAS) is now live on the Solana mainnet - an open, permissionless, verifiable credential protocol. SAS allows trusted issuers to associate off-chain information (such as KYC checks, geolocation qualifications, Clip membership, or certification status) with a user's wallet. These certifications are signed, verifiable, and reusable between applications without exposing sensitive data on the chain or repeating verification steps.

By providing a neutral and permissionless proof layer, SAS enables compliance, access control, reputation systems, and programmable identity across the Solana ecosystem. This results in a better, more convenient experience for end users and builders.

Attestation Service and Oracle are both mechanisms for bringing off-chain information to the chain, but their positioning, purpose, trust model and working methods are obviously different. Let's make a system comparison:

✅ A table to understand Attestation Service vs Oracle:

project

Attestation Service

Oracle

Main Application

Transform off-chain "subjective or static information such as identity, status, behavior, etc." into on-chain credentials

Feeding “objective, dynamic data” off-chain to the chain (such as price, weather, etc.)

Data Types

Subjective/event type: whether the person is over 18 years old, whether the person has passed the verification, whether the person is a member of a certain organization

Numerical/factual: BTC price, off-chain API data, weather data

Data Structure

Reusable, wallet-bound certification “claim”

Data used in real-time transactions (such as price feeds)

Trust Source

A "trusted publisher" (such as a KYC agency, DAO, or device manufacturer) signs the certificate

From multiple data sources, aggregated and published by the oracle network

Update frequency

Not frequent, often generated once and valid for a long time

High-frequency updates, such as updating prices every minute

Is it composable and reusable?

Yes, one authentication can be reused for multiple applications (such as KYC certification for a wallet)

No, price data is mainly an input to a transaction

Handling of privacy

Strong privacy protection, only verifying "whether it is passed" without disclosing detailed information

Usually does not involve user identity privacy

Representative projects/technologies

Solana Attestation Service, Ethereum Attestation Service (EAS)

Chainlink, Pyth, Band Protocol

🔍 Let’s take a comparative example

Attestation Service Use Case: You completed "real-name authentication" through a Web3 platform and obtained an on-chain certification stamp of "I am an adult". This stamp is stored in your wallet and can be verified by any dApp in the future without you having to resubmit your ID every time. Oracle Use Case: A DeFi protocol needs to know the current price of ETH to determine liquidation conditions. It reads the real-time ETH/USD price through an oracle (such as Chainlink). 🔑 The core difference can be summarized in one sentence:

The oracle is a "data feeding" mechanism that focuses on "objective facts" outside the chain; while the Attestation Service is a "authentication identity or status" mechanism that focuses on "subjective or conditional trust" outside the chain.

The two are complementary rather than substitutes.

Share to:

Author: Centreless

This article represents the views of PANews columnist and does not represent PANews' position or legal liability.

The article and opinions do not constitute investment advice

Image source: Centreless. Please contact the author for removal if there is infringement.

Follow PANews official accounts, navigate bull and bear markets together
Recommended Reading
1 hour ago
2 hour ago
2 hour ago
3 hour ago
3 hour ago
3 hour ago

Popular Articles

Industry News
Market Trends
Curated Readings

Curated Series

App内阅读